Why Terry Pluto thinks Sunday’s Browns vs. Texans matchup could be a ‘one-game tryout’ for Deshaun Watson
Rodney has spent over eight years reporting on Cleveland’s professional and amateur sports scenes, with a background in sports broadcasting from Bowling Green State University. He has contributed to ESPN Radio and other local stations, where his vibrant coverage has garnered a loyal following.
More from Rodney →
In this story
The air around Berea felt thick with speculation this week, thicker even than the November fog rolling off Lake Erie. Was Deshaun Watson truly back in the driver’s seat? Or was rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders poised to take over the Browns’ offense? The questions swirled, fueled by a coach’s initial reluctance to address the situation and a glimpse of what Sanders could offer in a stunning near-victory against the Saints. But on Wednesday, Head Coach Todd Monken finally put the rumors to rest: Deshaun Watson will indeed start Sunday against the Houston Texans, marking what veteran sports columnist Terry Pluto calls a “one-game tryout.”
What Happened: A Week of Uncertainty
The saga began last Thursday when Watson suffered a concussion during a loss against the Pittsburgh Steelers. He returned to the game briefly before being sidelined, and subsequently missed Sunday’s contest against New Orleans. In his absence, Sanders stepped in, showing flashes of promise despite the Browns’ heartbreaking 23-22 overtime defeat. Monken's subsequent silence on the quarterback situation only intensified the speculation that a change might be coming. He initially told reporters he needed to consult with his staff before making a decision, delaying the announcement until Wednesday.
“I had no intention of Deshaun not being our starter,” Monken stated, attempting to quell the rumors. He emphasized that Watson’s previous eight games of performance were a key factor in his decision. “Ultimately, the full body of work. Deshaun played pretty well.” The Browns’ history with quarterback instability undoubtedly contributed to the heightened anxiety among fans and media alike, making Monken's delayed statement all the more significant.
Watson himself seemed resigned to the situation, although his future beyond this week remains uncertain. “That’s up to Monk and the front office,” he said, referring to his continued role with the team. He is currently in the final year of a historic $240 million guaranteed contract – a deal that significantly reshaped both the Browns and the Texans franchises when he was acquired in 2022. The pressure is on to justify that investment.
Community Reaction: A Test of Faith and Performance
Fans Divided, Hope Remains
The Browns faithful are a passionate bunch, and the quarterback situation has become a source of considerable debate. The emergence of Sanders provided a glimmer of hope for a future beyond Watson, particularly given his struggles this season – most notably, he hasn't thrown a touchdown pass in three games. While many fans remain loyal to Watson, others are openly questioning whether he’s still the answer for Cleveland’s struggling offense, which currently ranks 29th in scoring. The hope is that Sunday’s game against his former team will provide a clear indication of Watson's ability to lead the Browns back into contention.
Monken's Ambiguity Fuels Speculation
Monken’s evasiveness this week hasn’t helped soothe the anxieties. His statement that “I don’t look at it week to week and I don't look at his long term,” further fuels speculation about Watson’s future with the team. While he insists that Watson is the starter, Monken added, “We’re judged each week. I am. He is. Our team is.” This ambiguity suggests that Watson's performance against the Texans will be heavily scrutinized, and a significant misstep could open the door for Sanders to reclaim the starting role.
What's Next: A Critical Game and a Look Ahead
The Browns’ upcoming schedule presents both opportunities and challenges. Sunday’s game against the Texans is more than just another contest; it's an opportunity for Watson to regain his rhythm and demonstrate his value. Following the game, the Browns will enjoy a bye week, providing valuable time for rest and reflection before facing a crucial stretch of three consecutive home games. This period will be critical in determining whether Watson can solidify his position as the team’s long-term quarterback or if Sanders will be given another chance to prove himself.
Monken also addressed other team matters, noting that rookie WR Denzel Boston (toe) is in a walking boot, though he expects him to practice Thursday. The coach also stated that there are no planned changes to the offensive line despite recent penalties. Defensive tackle Maliek Collins (elbow/illness) has returned to practice after missing Sunday's game, while several other players remain out due to injury: Ronnie Hickman (concussion), Elgton Jenkins (knee), and Michael Burton (calf). Cleveland Browns News via the team's official website.
Rodney’s Take: A Crossroads for Cleveland
What we’re witnessing in Cleveland isn’t just a quarterback controversy; it’s a reflection of a larger challenge facing the city – the pursuit of sustained success after significant investment. The $240 million guaranteed to Watson represented a massive bet on his ability to lead the Browns back to championship contention. While he's shown flashes of brilliance, his recent struggles and the emergence of Sanders force us to confront a difficult question: has this gamble paid off? It's easy to get caught up in the drama, but at its core, this situation underscores the importance of stability and leadership – values that resonate deeply within our community. Strong families need a steady hand at the helm, and so does a football team striving for greatness. The next few weeks will be pivotal, not just for the Browns’ playoff hopes, but also for the long-term direction of the franchise and the faith of its fans.
Resources for Browns Fans
For those looking to stay informed about the Cleveland Browns, here are some helpful resources:
- Cleveland Browns Official Website: The official source for team news, schedules, and more.
- ESPN Cleveland Browns Coverage: Comprehensive coverage from ESPN's sports reporting team.
- Akron Beacon Journal Browns Coverage: Local news and analysis from the Akron area.
- City of Cleveland Website: Information about city events and resources.
- Cleveland.com Browns Coverage: Updates and analysis from cleveland.com’s Browns reporters.
- Cleveland Browns YouTube Channel: Video highlights and behind-the-scenes content.
- Pro-Football-Reference Browns Page: Detailed statistics and historical data for the Browns franchise.
- Browns on Twitter: Real-time updates and news from the Browns' official Twitter account.
- Sports Illustrated Browns Coverage: National perspective on the Browns and their players.
The Browns’ journey this season is a testament to the unpredictable nature of professional sports and the enduring passion of Cleveland fans. As they prepare to face the Texans, one thing is clear: the stakes are high, and the future of their quarterback position hangs in the balance.
For families in Northeast Ohio, seeing a team compete at a high level brings a sense of pride and community. The Browns represent more than just a football team; they embody the spirit of Cleveland – resilience, determination, and an unwavering belief in the possibility of greatness. Let's hope for a game filled with grit, determination, and ultimately, victory for the Browns.